Tools like ancestry.com, ftdna and 23andme will give you an overall admixture (I am 3% Lithuanian, for instance). That overall admixture is impossible to use as a clue in gene to gene comparison of matches. You could both share African descent, for instance - and it could be from entirely different ancestors. Lo, the African continent happens to be pretty vast and offers billions of possible ancestors! To find the admixture that is relevant to a particular match, you have to get more granular - down to the segments within a gene. Only gedmatch offers the tools to do that at this time.
These instructions will help you find out if the DNA you and you and your genetic cousin have in common has a particular admixture. It is roughly the process I used to find Millie Turner and Samuel Hussey in my genetic makeup.Although this will not prove a MRCA, it will provide more clues or evidence.
The following caveats apply :
- An admixture tool is only as good as it's sample size and population. For instance, if the sample didn't include any people of African descent, it will not pick up African admixture. For this reason, different admixture tools interpret genes differently so you might not get a completely straight forward answer. My experience is that you will find one or two admixture tools that do a better job than others of approximating your admixture - and that will differ from person to person.
- When you look at the admixture of a specific gene, for yourself, for instance, you are seeing what you got from BOTH parents. To find out which admixture on a particular gene came from which parent, you would run through these instructions first to compare yourself to one parent or the other.
- Not sharing the admixture of the ethnicity of the ancestor does NOT mean you do not have that ancestor in common. It could mean that, through recombination, across generations, you just don't have any genes from that ancestor or not enough for it to accurately show up in admixture analysis.
- If your genetic makeup has the admixture of the ancestor in common that also does NOT mean you are definitely related to that person. So, if you have African admixture, that does not prove you are related to the African ancestor in question. You might have other African ancestors that you don't know about yet.